| Year | Player | All American Team |
|---|---|---|
| 2024 | Bradyn Hubbard | NJCAA 1st Team |
| 2023 | Xavier Glenn | NJCAA Honorable Mention |
| 2021 | Jahcoree Ealy | NJCAA Honorable Mention |
| 2018 | Ra'Shawn Langston | NJCAA 2nd Team |
| 2017 | Adarius Avery | NJCAA Honorable Mention |
| 2016 | Devin Simms | NJCAA 1st Team |
| 2015 | Corlbe Ervin | NJCAA 1st Team |
| 2015 | Ronnie Boyce | NJCAA 3rd Team |
| 2014 | Willie Atwood | NJCAA 3rd Team |
| 2011 | Robert Crawford | NJCAA Honorable Mention |
| 2011 | Corey Wilford | NJCAA 2nd Tean |
| 2010 | C.J. Washington | NJCAA 1st Team |
| 2009 | Stephon Weaver | NJCAA 3rd Team |
| 2006 | Al Weber | NJCAA Honorable Mention. |
| 1999 | Kenny Dye | NJCAA 3rd Team |
| 1998 | Kenny Dye | NJCAA Honorable Mention. |
| 1997 | Detrick White | NJCAA 1st Team |
| 1996 | Horatio Webster | NJCAA 1st Team |
| 1994 | Simeon Haley | NJCAA Honorable Mention. |
| 1994 | Samie Haley | NJCAA 3rd Team |
| 1994 | Cyrus Jones | NJCAA 1st Team |
| 1993 | Frank Harris | NJCAA 3rd Team |
| 1990 | Elmore Spencer | NJCAA 1st Team |
| 1980 | Eddie Louie | NJCAA 1st Team |
| 1978 | Richard Williams | NJCAA 2nd Team |
| 1976 | James Bradley | NJCAA Honorable Mention. |
| 1974 | Odis Young | NJCAA Honorable Mention. |